Elon Musk is ‘distracted’, a ‘top risk’ for Tesla, say investors: Report says

Rival automakers are emerging as the primary challenge for Tesla in the next two years, capitalizing on the surging demand for electric vehicles (EVs). This challenge is amplified by the fact that Tesla’s CEO, Elon Musk, appears to be distracted by his involvement in various high-profile ventures such as social media, space travel, and artificial intelligence.

According to respondents in the Markets Live Pulse survey, 54% of the 630 global contributors highlighted the intensified risk of industry competition, while 26% expressed concerns about Musk’s behavior and decision-making, considering him to be a key concern for Tesla shareholders.

Matthew Tuttle, CEO of Tuttle Capital Management, stated in an interview that Musk’s unpredictability makes him one of the top risks for Tesla. The survey participants, comprising 67% of the total, believed that Musk should concentrate more on the carmaker as profit margins become thinner.

Despite these concerns, Tesla’s stock experienced a remarkable rally of 128% this year, driven by renewed investor interest in tech megacaps and Musk’s claim that fully autonomous vehicles are on the horizon.

Although Tesla currently holds a significant lead over other companies, its valuation largely relies on the assumption that it will maintain its dominance in a future where EVs become more prevalent. However, competitors are catching up quickly.

For instance, China’s BYD Co. achieved record sales in the second quarter, delivering 352,163 fully electric vehicles, while Tesla handed over 466,140 EVs worldwide, also an all-time high.

While some argue that Tesla’s rivals are still grappling with initial challenges, analysts and investors warn that Tesla’s advantage can diminish rapidly as government policies, like the US’s Inflation Reduction Act, incentivize other automakers to embrace EVs.

With competitors intensifying their efforts, Tesla’s highly priced shares, trading at 75 times forward earnings, provide little room for error. In comparison, General Motors (GM) trades at approximately 6 times estimated profits, and Ford trades at about 9 times.

Craig Irwin, an analyst at Roth Capital Partners, emphasized that competition is the most significant risk factor for Tesla in the long term. Even mediocre execution from the approximately 100 new EVs entering the market this year could exert pressure on Tesla. While its current lead is substantial, understanding how it will shrink is crucial.

To defend its market share, Tesla is expected to continue lowering prices, as predicted by 63% of the MLIV Pulse respondents. Consequently, the company’s profit margin, which is already taking a hit, will likely face further reduction, narrowing the gap with other auto companies.

The impact of recent price cuts on Tesla’s profits will be evident when the company reports its second-quarter results. The average profit estimate for the quarter has decreased by 29% over the past six months.

Nicholas Colas of DataTrek Research emphasized that winning stocks grow revenue and margins, highlighting the importance of both factors. Additionally, the “Musk-risk” embedded in Tesla shares gained attention last year when Musk made a highly publicized bid for the social media platform Twitter and sold off significant portions of Tesla stock to fund the acquisition.

The pressure stemming from these sales, coupled with concerns about Musk’s ability to effectively manage Tesla, heavily impacted the company’s shares. It is worth noting that Twitter’s value has also dwindled, with 67% of survey respondents doubting it will ever be worth as much as Musk paid for it.

Overall, while Tesla currently enjoys a considerable lead in the EV market, rival automakers are rapidly catching up. The intense competition, combined with concerns about Musk’s focus and decision-making, pose significant challenges for the company. With Tesla’s profit margins thinning, analysts and investors are wary of its highly valued shares, which leave little room for error.

As Tesla continues to defend its market share through price reductions, its profit margin will face further pressure, narrowing the gap with other auto companies. Ultimately, maintaining dominance in the face of competition and ensuring profitable growth will be critical for Tesla’s long-term success.

Furthermore, the distractions posed by Elon Musk’s involvement in other ventures have raised concerns among investors and analysts. Musk’s previous bid for Twitter and the subsequent sale of Tesla stock to fund the acquisition highlighted the “Musk-risk” embedded in Tesla shares.

During that time, the market expressed worries that Musk had become too distracted to effectively lead Tesla, which resulted in a significant decline in the company’s stock value. The survey respondents echoed these concerns, with 26% identifying Musk’s behavior and decisions as a key risk for Tesla.

Moreover, Tesla’s high valuation is heavily reliant on its ability to maintain dominance in a future where EVs become mainstream. However, the landscape is evolving rapidly, driven by government policies that encourage the adoption of EVs.

For instance, the US Inflation Reduction Act incentivizes other automakers to embrace electric vehicles, potentially eroding Tesla’s current advantage. As a result, analysts and investors emphasize that Tesla’s lead over the competition is not guaranteed, and even moderate execution from the numerous new EVs entering the market this year could put pressure on the company.

To counter this competition and defend its market share, Tesla is likely to continue lowering prices. Around 63% of the survey participants expect Tesla to reduce prices further to capture higher volumes. While this strategy may help maintain market share, it comes at the expense of profit margins.

Already, Tesla’s profit margin has been affected, and further price cuts could narrow the gap between Tesla and other auto companies, potentially impacting its financial performance and investor sentiment.

The impact of these price cuts on Tesla’s profitability will be revealed when the company reports its second-quarter results. Analysts have already lowered their profit estimates for the quarter by 29% compared to six months ago, indicating the anticipated effect on Tesla’s financials.

This shift in profitability is significant, as winning stocks are expected to grow both revenue and margins. Tesla will need to find a delicate balance between maintaining its market share and sustaining healthy profit margins to continue satisfying investor expectations.

The competition in the EV market is not limited to established automakers. Startups and companies from various regions, particularly China, are also entering the scene with ambitious plans and growing sales figures.

China’s BYD Co., for example, achieved record-breaking sales in the second quarter, indicating its rapid progress in catching up with Tesla. While some competitors may still be grappling with initial challenges, their continuous improvement and government support could erode Tesla’s current lead.

Considering Tesla’s highly valued shares, which trade at 75 times forward earnings, there is little room for error. Investors are increasingly cautious about the company’s stock, particularly in comparison to more established automakers like General Motors and Ford, which trade at significantly lower price-to-earnings ratios. This valuation discrepancy suggests that investors perceive higher risk associated with Tesla, given its reliance on maintaining dominance in a fiercely competitive market.

In conclusion, Tesla faces significant challenges from rival automakers capitalizing on the growing demand for electric vehicles. These competitors, combined with concerns about Elon Musk’s distractions and decision-making, pose risks to Tesla’s future success.

As the EV market evolves and government policies encourage wider adoption of electric vehicles, Tesla’s current advantage may erode. The company’s focus on defending its market share through price reductions could impact its profit margins and narrow the gap with other auto companies. Tesla’s ability to navigate these challenges, maintain dominance, and sustain profitability will be crucial for its long-term growth and investor confidence.

Also Read:

1 thought on “Elon Musk is ‘distracted’, a ‘top risk’ for Tesla, say investors: Report says”

Leave a Comment